Decoding PLC vs. Computer Programming: Key Differences Unveiled


Updated on:

Have you ever wondered what sets Programmable Logic Controllers (PLCs) apart from your regular computer programming? I’ve spent years delving deep into the world of electronics and automation, and I know firsthand the importance of understanding the differences between these two distinct systems.

PLCs have been the backbone of automation for decades, but with the rise of computer programming, many are questioning whether this old technology is still relevant. While there are similarities between the two, the way in which they function and are implemented is vastly different.

If you’re a professional in the world of automation or just a curious mind, keep reading to learn about the key differences between PLCs and computer programming, and why understanding these differences is crucial in keeping your systems running smoothly and safely. Let’s dive in.

What is the difference between PLC and computer programming?

PLC and computer programming differ in various aspects, which can affect the fundamentals of how programs are designed, developed, and executed. One of the main differences between a PLC and a PC is the method of program execution. PLCs use a scan-based method of execution while PC programs rely on event-driven methods. Below are some crucial differences between PLC and computer programming:

  • Programming Language: The primary programming language in PLCs is Ladder Logic, whereas various programming languages such as C++ and Python are commonly used in computer programming.
  • Hardware: The hardware in a PLC is specifically designed to run industrial processes, making it better suited for industrial automation purposes. On the other hand, PC hardware is designed for general computing tasks and can be used for various applications.
  • Real-time capabilities: PLCs have precise real-time capabilities that are appropriate for controlling industrial processes. Computer programming, on the other hand, may experience delays due to the operating system and hardware limitations.
  • Scalability: Both PLC and computer programming are scalable, but the methods used for scaling are different. In a PLC, scaling is achieved by adding hardware modules, while in programming, it’s achieved through software development.
  • Security: PLC programming is typically designed with security in mind. Since it controls machinery and critical industrial processes, it’s crucial to ensure that unauthorized entities cannot access the system. Computer programming, on the other hand, requires more security measures to protect against cyber-attacks.
  • In conclusion, there are essential differences between PLC and computer programming you should consider when designing and implementing automation systems. If you wish to develop automation applications that require real-time capabilities and stability, then PLC programming is the most suitable choice. Nonetheless, if you’re looking to develop general computing applications that require more flexibility and scalability, computer programming may be your best option.

    ???? Pro Tips:

    1. PLC programming emphasizes real-time response, while computer programming is often more flexible and powerful. It’s important to understand the unique strengths and weaknesses of each approach to choose the right tool for the job.

    2. In PLC programming, the focus is on controlling physical processes, such as machine movements or sensor inputs. In computer programming, the focus is more on data processing and manipulation. Understanding the different domains of each approach can help you make informed decisions.

    3. One key difference between PLC and computer programming is the level of abstraction involved. PLC programming typically involves a very low-level, hardware-specific approach to control, while computer programming can leverage higher-level abstractions that make development faster and more efficient.

    4. When choosing between PLC and computer programming, consider the specific requirements of your project. Factors like cost, performance, and accessibility can all play a role in determining which approach is best.

    5. It’s worth noting that many modern industrial control systems combine elements of both PLC and computer programming, allowing for greater flexibility and scalability. Understanding the strengths of each approach can help you create powerful and effective control systems that meet the needs of your organization.

    Overview of PLC Programming

    A Programmable Logic Controller, or PLC, is a digital computer designed to automate industrial processes. PLC programming is a type of programming that is used to develop programs that can control PLCs. A PLC programming language consists of a set of instructions that are executed in real-time to control the process. The main advantages of PLC programming include reliability, speed, and flexibility. Most importantly, a PLC can be programmed to perform many complicated tasks that are difficult or impossible to do manually.

    PLC programming is often used to control machines or systems in manufacturing facilities or other industrial settings. The programs are typically developed using ladder logic, which is a graphical programming language that resembles a ladder. This language uses symbols and diagrams to represent the logical relationships between different components of a system. The programs are usually executed in a continuous loop, allowing the PLC to monitor and control the process in real-time.

    Overview of Computer Programming

    Computer programming refers to the process of designing and writing instructions that can be executed by a computer. The process of computer programming involves developing a set of algorithms and implementing them in a programming language. Computer programs can be used to solve a variety of problems and automate many different types of tasks. Additionally, computer programming has the advantage of being able to handle complex calculations and data analysis tasks.

    Computer programming languages come in many different forms, including high-level and low-level languages. High-level languages like Python and Java are used to develop applications and user interfaces, while low-level languages like C and Assembly are used to develop operating systems and device drivers. Computer programs can be executed on a variety of different devices, ranging from PCs and laptops to smartphones and embedded systems.

    Methods of Program Execution on PLC and PC

    One of the main differences between PLC programming and computer programming is the way in which programs are executed. PLC programs typically use a scan-based execution method, while PC programs use an event-driven method.

    Scan-Based Execution on PLC

    PLC programs use a scan-based execution method, which involves repeatedly scanning the system to monitor inputs, execute logic, and update outputs. The scan cycle consists of several stages, including the input stage, logic stage, and output stage. During the input stage, the PLC reads input signals from sensors and other devices connected to the system. During the logic stage, the PLC processes the input signals using the programmed logic. Finally, during the output stage, the PLC sends output signals to actuators and other devices connected to the system.

    Event-Driven Execution on PC

    PC programs use an event-driven execution method, which involves responding to events and messages from the system. The events can be triggered by user input, hardware events, or software events. When an event occurs, the program responds by executing the appropriate code. Event-driven programming is typically used in applications that require user interaction, such as graphical user interfaces, web applications, and video games.

    Programming Principles for PLC and PC

    PLC programming and computer programming also differ in terms of the principles they use to develop programs.

    PLC Programming Principles

    PLC programming typically follows a set of principles called IEC 61131-3. This standard defines a set of programming languages and guidelines for developing PLC programs. The main programming languages used in PLC programming are ladder logic, function block diagram, structured text, and sequential function chart. PLC programming principles prioritize stability, reliability, and predictability above all else.

    Computer Programming Principles

    Computer programming follows a variety of different principles, depending on the programming language and application. Some of the common principles include object-oriented programming, functional programming, and procedural programming. Computer programming principles prioritize efficiency, flexibility, and scalability above all else.

    Comparison of PLC and Computer Programming

    In summary, PLC programming and computer programming are two very different approaches to programming that are used for different purposes. PLC programming is used to automate industrial processes and control machines, while computer programming is used to develop applications and solve complex computational problems.

    PLC programming follows a set of principles designed to prioritize stability and reliability, while computer programming prioritizes efficiency and flexibility. Additionally, PLC programs use a scan-based execution method, while PC programs use an event-driven method.

    Overall, both PLC programming and computer programming are valuable tools for solving complex problems and automating tasks. Which one you use will depend on your specific needs and the nature of your project.